| Platinum | Bello Cucina |
| Gold | Olive Garden Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | House of Pizza |
| Bronze | Pasta Buckets |
| Top Pick | DiMaggio's Pizza and Pasta |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's Italian Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Jules' Bistro |
| Top Pick | New York Gyro |
| Top Pick | Olde Brick House |
| Top Pick | The White Horse Restaurant & Bar |